Queenstown news and more...

10/02/2012

School fan plan for art students’ fume room

DislikeDislike (1)
LikeLike (1)
adjust text size - small adjust text size - medium adjust text size - large adjust text size - extra large

 
 

Wakatipu High students having “light-headed” experiences in fume-ridden art classes will soon be brought back down to earth. 

The school is rushing to splash out on large extractor fans for the room so students no longer suffer the mind-bending effects of potent solvents sniffed accidentally during class. 

Students approached by Mountain Scene tell how sometimes it’s been bad enough to make kids ask to leave lessons because of the strong pong from toxic chemicals like turps, methylated spirits and polyurethane. 

Year 12’s Ariana Horsley says some kids get headaches when solvents are used but “you get used to it”.
“You get a bit light-headed,” she adds. 

Papers from a school Board of Trustees meeting last December reveal the teacher in charge of art Leslie Koehn as saying ventilation is a “big issue” in the class. 

“The art room in Robertson Block has very little ventilation and students often use thinners and solvents for transferring images,” the report says. 

“Students have been working on the balcony at times but this is not suitable.” 

Principal Lyn Cooper insists the school’s never had complaints from students working in the large “poorly-designed” room with only small opening windows positioned up high. But she says the school is now shopping for extractor fans. 

“We’ve had to do modifications to ensure health and safety,” Cooper says. 

A budget for the fans hasn’t been set but the school will call for tenders soon. 

“If we get fans we don’t have to have [the kids] outside.” 

Student Ariana Horsley, who doesn’t take art this year, confirms some lessons have had to be moved outdoors. 

“You just sit in class and say, ‘Oh, Miss’. You have to ask if you can go outside to do it.” 

Her friend Jordan Howell adds: “Quite a few kids can’t stand it and have to leave.” 

But both girls say they’ve never thought it’s a health and safety issue. 

Friend Holly Bain plays down any concern: “It’s nothing major.” 

Art teacher Koehn tells Mountain Scene she referred to ventilation as a “big issue” at last year’s BoT meeting because it was part of a “wish list” for the department. 

“It would be a total blowing up of something if that was to be made an issue. 

“Once or twice in the year – and it’s my choice whether I want to use it – we use thinners-based products and the students decide that they want to go for that technique. It can be very smelly but we go out onto the deck and try to avoid the fumes inside. 

“It’s a very minor issue and if anyone suffers, it’s me,” she says. 

Koehn says she won’t be using thinners again “until we get the fans installed”. 

“It would be such a horrible thing if parents read this and thought their children were in danger in the art room.” 

Dunedin-based National Poisons Centre director Dr Wayne Temple says short-term exposure to solvents can lead to headaches, nausea, drowsiness, skin problems and affect coordination. 

“It [can be] particularly bad in winter if all the windows are closed and there’s not much ventilation and it’s fairly hot – that can obviously exacerbate the situation so that’s not a good scene as well.” 

Without knowing exposure levels, Temple can’t say what sort of effect there may be on students but “obviously having a good change of ventilation and fresh air is a good thing to do”.

Your say

Most Poorly Researched and Obviously Biased Story in the Scene Award
Congratulations to ms. Celia Williams, who has won our online poll for 'Most Poorly Researched and Obviously Biased Story in the Scene' for this week. Best of luck for next week, voting opens in our facebook group on thursday.
21 Mar 2010 10:59AM Babbage
 
Excuse me?
I honestly cannot begin to describe my disgust over this. The fact that this cretin of a woman and the Mountain Scene allowed such an article to be published really makes me reconsider the quality and reliability of this News Paper. And to think that she was meant to be reporting on Rowing, not even on the schools art department.
I've been a student of Wakatipu High School for 7 years now, 3 of which i have done art, and the thinner fumes where HARDLY a problem what so ever. We did it all outside on a desk anyway.
To say i am disappointed in the Mountain Scene right now is an understatement. Get your grossly misleading facts straight please.
20 Mar 2010 12:16AM Student
 
you have got to be kidding.
I am horrified that a local newspaper would write such a disgusting article about their local school. You’re paper really needs to get their facts straight before you write about a school getting ‘high’ off fumes. The image is obscene, a flying pig… really? Ms Celia Williams is an crap reporter and it seems she must be ‘high’ herself to really believe that the information that she is telling the public and visitors to Queenstown is correct. Well I better get to the school my ‘high’ is wearing off!!!
19 Mar 2010 11:14AM Yamaha
 
Are you calling them druggies?
This article has been a cause for concern amongst students. They feel offended and hurt at the reputation being implied by Ms. Williams- that the school is using products equalling that of a drug user looking to go on 'mind bending' trips. The image, on the front page no less, is proposterous. It would be laughable if it wasn't damaging for the school's reputation. Students are genuinely upset they are being put in the position of now having to defend themselves against these lies that their health and safety are in jepoardy.
This article is degrading and disrespectful to teachers, parents and students associated with Wakatipu High School.
So Ms. Williams? are you calling them druggies? or what. get your facts straight, find some proper news to write about and don't hound young girls who you were supposed to be interviewing about rowing. In a community like this you can't afford to drag the only high school in the area's, name through mud.
19 Mar 2010 11:11AM cort
 
Concerned student
I have been a student in the art department for the last 4 years and have never had concerns for my safety or the safety of other students. Mrs Koehn is very particular about who can use the thinners and where they can use them. Thinners are only ever used on final peices hence a senior student would generally only use them one or twice during the year, and they would certainly not be using substantial amounts of them capable of causing side effects.
19 Mar 2010 10:59AM Concerned_student
 
Blatant sensationalism
The recent article in the Mountain Scene, Celia Williams’ ‘School fan plan for student fume room’ (also headed ‘Waka-sniffu High’ on the front page graphic and ‘High times at Waka High’ on the newstand), is quite frankly offensive, sensationalist, and intentionally misleading. This article is damaging to both the school’s reputation and that of the student body, who Ms. Williams so boldly ‘defended’ in another article several weeks ago -again a disproportionate and one-sided attack on the school regarding a very poorly informed and explained version of the ‘new’ policy of streaming classes according to age, not ability.
This new blast is in similar vein, seizing upon what Leslie Koehn, the TIC of art, is quoted as calling (although notably on page 2 of the article) ‘a very minor issue’, and turning it into an insinuation of health code violations and even implying potential damage to students. This is, quoting from the article itself, totally ‘blowing [it] up’ out of proportion.
The story itself is not overly exciting -every year the school departments make ‘wish lists’ of requests to the BOT, and this year the arts department brought up the idea of installing extractor fans in the art room, as -as is obvious to even those of us who are not in touch with the National Poisons Center director -paint, when inhaled, can cause negative effects. The effect is even worse when using thinners and solvents, optional parts of the arts course that, as Ms. Koehn says, are only used once or twice a year at discretion of both teacher and student. Needless to say, all students are warned of the dangers of getting their noses too close to the paint before beginning work.
However, Ms. Williams, on seeing this motion in the BOT’s published report of its meeting, has leaped on the offensive. While she is careful never to let her narrative stray far from fact, she casts the entire episode in an entirely negative light.
Suddenly, students who are feeling the effects of the paint and want to move outside, are suffering the ‘mind-bending effects of potent solvents’ and having to leave for fear, it is implied, of their health. The BOT and principal, instead of addressing an issue raised by one of their heads of department, are now ‘rushing to splash out on large extractor fans’. This is a gross twisting of facts. If this article was published last year, when there was still an unaddressed need for extractor fans, then this article would be understandable. But now that the school is attempting to do something about it, they are being slammed.
What is even worse is the manner in which Ms. Williams obtained her quotes from the young year twelve girls interviewed for the article. In her piece, it almost looks as though the girls turned to her, and to the Mountain Scene, in a desperate cry for help, although of course this is not explicitly stated -mainly because they were not even interviewed specifically about this issue. The three girls were being interviewed by Ms. W
18 Mar 2010 08:56PM Babbage
 
Have your say

You will need to register or login before you can post a comment.